well, the movie starts with a new kind of starter…applauds….very appealing.very precisely would give 4 star …excellent screen play,excellent acting by the lead and all other imtiaz patent actors,the only fault lies in the subject ,which has been told,and retold ample no of times,unfortunately the subject needs lot of work to be done,it has been put on the screen with way back research already done,so we want something new atleast this is wat expected out of imtiaz direction,although the movie intrigues through out 2 and a half hour but subject need to be more researched ,infact a lot researched……we are not happy until we are what we are!…but it been told in three idiots and many other previous movies…the way subject has been presented is no doubt flawless….but philosophical growth is certainly required in the subject .